What Modern Marketers Should Expect From A Direct Mail Partner

By Carl Garnett, managing director of Telescope.

When I started out, most brands had a print buyer, someone who knew how a catalogue came together and how long an envelope took to produce. That role has largely disappeared, and the marketers I work with now have mostly come up through digital and data instead. They’re far sharper on analytics and testing than most print buyers ever needed to be.

That’s good news for direct mail, which has become as much a data channel as a print one. It does change what a brand should expect from its partner, though. Nobody running a modern marketing team should really need to know how an envelope is made or which format will save them money on postage. That knowledge belongs with the partner, along with the experience to spot what will lift a response before anything goes to print, so the marketer can spend their time on the strategy and the customer. Keeping the data safe and getting the mailing out on time are where that relationship starts, and a lot of data never gets used for much beyond them.

What should you look for in the partner handling your data?

The opportunity in customer data has grown enormously over the years, and it’s still growing. Brands can now see how their customers shop, what they open, where they came from, what they bought last and what they’re likely to want next. The brands pulling ahead tend to be working with partners who do something with all of that, picking out the patterns and turning them into sharper, more profitable communication. If you’re weighing up who should handle your data, I’d look for that instinct to make it work harder above most other things.

Does your partner work like part of your team?

The partnerships that work best tend to stop feeling like an outside supplier and start to feel more like an extension of the client’s own team. Once people know the account, the customers and the goals, briefings get shorter and there’s far less explaining to do. Ideas often follow from that familiarity as well, whether it’s a smarter way to segment a mailing, an offer for a group nobody had thought to target or a quicker route to the same result. Get to that point and a client can ring with an objective, say a new store opening or a range they need to push, and leave the partner to come back with how to do it.

What should happen to your data once it’s been cleaned?

Deduplicating a file and running suppression against people who’ve moved, opted out or sadly passed away is basic housekeeping, and any good partner should be doing it as a matter of course. It stops you paying to print and post to people who were never going to respond, and it avoids the sort of mistake that upsets customers and reflects badly on your brand.

Most of the gains tend to come afterwards, because once a customer’s activity is brought together into a single customer view, across the shop, website, email and mail, it becomes much clearer who’s likely to respond and why. You can model that, target it, and put your direct mail budget where it will actually return something. Not long ago this sort of modelling was mostly the preserve of the biggest players; it’s well within reach of most brands now. For one client we run a live database of more than eight million individuals, updated daily, and what that makes possible suggests most brands are sitting on far more than they realise.

Are your product data and artwork under proper control?

Product information and creative assets need the same discipline as customer data, and they’re often where avoidable errors creep in.

Product information management (PIM) gives you one reliable source for every product detail. Change a price or a specification once and it flows out accurately to your catalogue, your website and everywhere else it appears, which spares you the familiar problem of the same wrong figure turning up in three places, or a change arriving after the catalogue has already gone to print. Digital asset management (DAM) brings that same order to artwork and brand assets, so files are logically named, version-controlled and quick to find, and nothing goes missing when a colleague moves on. For any brand producing catalogues or campaigns at volume, getting PIM and DAM right removes a whole category of mistakes before anyone has to spot them.

How can you tell your data is genuinely safe?

Independent accreditation is one of the clearest ways to check whether a partner is keeping your data safe. Handing over your customers’ personal information is a big act of trust, and GDPR compliance ought to be something you can see working in practice. ISO 27001 for information security and ISO 9001 for quality are both audited by outside assessors with no reason to go easy on anyone, so they give you something firmer to go on than reassurance. They save time too, because procurement and security teams increasingly treat those certificates as the gate, and a partner who holds them will already have answered most of the questions on the checklist. Whether they hold them is a fair question to put to anyone handling your data. As for AI, at the moment it belongs in speeding up a partner’s own work and well away from your customers’ information, certainly until the safeguards are in place and its safe use on customer data becomes the industry benchmark.

Can one partner handle the whole job?

Every extra supplier your data and campaigns pass through means another handoff and another set of versions floating about, and each of those is a chance for something to slip. Keeping the data, the print and the direct mail in one place takes out most of that risk. It also makes life simpler for the client, who can give one team the whole thing (data, print, direct mail, design, digital, even events and the occasional piece nobody’s made before) instead of coordinating five suppliers or keeping specialist knowledge in-house for work that comes round twice a year.

That thinking was behind a decision we made this year to bring our own data specialism fully in-house. We’d worked closely with a specialist data business for a long time, and we’ve now integrated it completely, as part of the same operation under the same roof rather than a separate department, because it never made much sense to me to have the data sitting apart from everything it feeds.

What it comes down to

Brands are entitled to expect a lot from whoever handles their data and their marketing. Today’s marketers have the data skills and the strategic thinking covered, and alongside that they need a partner who knows the craft of direct mail inside out. That partner should also be keeping their data and product information under proper control, and looking for the opportunities they’d otherwise miss. Whether that’s really happening is the question I’d put to any partner, ours included, and I’d hold us to it, because it’s how I’ve always thought business should be done: openly and accurately, with the client and the people doing the work both getting something out of it.